WayneB wrote:
I know what you mean, but what I really love about being into the electronic music scene is the unrivalled diversity of it. With a lot of bands you need a drummer, bassist, guitarist and singer, they need loads of practice to get any good, they need to get out there and the ones that make it big seem to usually because they have a commercial appeal. For "good" electronic music the opposite is true. With the exponential advancements in music technology even a 15 year old kid with his Dads laptop can now make incredbily complex, beautiful, hard, underground tracks, and thanks to the internet with sites like Beatport all this music is there for the taking. I've been called small-minded before for only being into electronic stuff (even though I love classical) yet to me electronica is the most open-minded genre there is, filled with a near infinite number of individual idioms that refuse to be categorised or subcategorised.
A rock album is often just that, an album full of rock tracks. Same goes for rap and the dreaded R&B. However the great electronic albums such as Jilted, Leftism, Protection / Mezzanine, Leave home etc are so fantastic as they encompass such a huge range of styles and influences into what is collectively an electronic album, yet they are so, so much more. Liam has got this down to a fine art which is why I believe he is the top of this particular game.
As for the rockers I know (and back when the Prodigy started for 95% of people I grew up with it was all about rock for many years it seemed) I just don't understand how these people hated Experience & Jilted, but after getting into FOTL they suddenly began to like it. The music never changed, it just seemed to me they liked the rockier tracks like FS and onwards but forced themselves to accept the earlier stuff and deluded themselves into thinking that they liked it because they had to due to loving the newer, rockier stuff. This may come across as arrogant but I've never let that stop me, if you don't consider artists like Leftfield, Massive Attack, Underworld, Orbital, Chemical Brothers (pre-block rockin' beats anyway), Aphex Twin, FSOL etc to be your top bands, then why do you listen to the Prodigy at all? These were their contemporaries, if you didn't like them back in the day then you didn't like the Prodigy either. At least that is how it worked with the people I grew up with. At the end of the day I might not like the new fanbase (especially the way they seem to me to have totally overlooked what the Prodigy was about and what it stood for, but also the agressive nature of a lot of the gigs now) but more fans means more money for the band which means more tracks being written and more tours to promote them. It's a necessary evil in my mind. After all if FS and FOTL had been flops then who's to say the Prodigy would not have gone Kaput after '97?
I personally do wish the Prodigy were just an act loved by the electronic crew, not just for my own selfish reasons and desire for a return to "my" Prodigy of old, but also because I have a long memory and remember the amount of stick, not to mention constantly feeling left out and ostracized because some of us loved music, we didn't just love what everyone else did to fit in, be cool, and be popular.
However, he who laughs last.......
Sorry for being off topic but I have to add a comment to your post.
I haven't been a 'true' Prodigy fan for nearly as long as you have but I've done my research. I even bought a biography of the Prodigy written by Martin James for 2$ at a local HMV and I read the whole thing in a week just to learn everything I absolutely could about the band that I love the most. One quote that stood out to me was said by Liam and it went something like: "I don't want the Prodigy to be one of those bands that you listen to a few times then get bored of the tracks, I want people to slowly discover us." Maybe you have an excellent ear for quality Breaks and got into The Prodigy in their early stages but there's no reason why someone can't be pulled in by their later work (FotL on) then slowly discover the greatness of Experience and Jilted. Hell, I know I did. My opinion of certain songs changed over time, as I became more intimate with each one, which is what Liam intended from the start. If that makes me a poser, so be it

.